Looks like you had a great trip. You seemed to get a lot packed in to each day. My sister and I are going in November and plan to put as much into each day as possible. Hope it works out for us as well!
Last year I went to NY and thought I saw it all, and since I'll be returning next summer I wanted to see what I missed. I've never heard of Una Pizza Napoletana, or PJ Clarke's. Thanks for the detailed heads up on what to get, very helpful!
Yeah it is nearly impossible to see it all in cities like NY, but if you don't mind spending some money on a pizza then Una Pizza Napoletana is fantastic. I also thought P.J. Clarkes was one of my favorite places in all of NY but you will probably have to wait and the bar is typically crowded but it adds to the atmosphere. I would also recommend Pies N Thighs 2 if it opens for something a little different. The Pies N Thighs we went to closed but a new one is being planned.