The best place I found to stay in Hocking Hills was Hickory Grove Cabins, They are located in the center of Hocking Hills and close to everything. The web site is http://www.hickorygroveretreat.com
I was scared of getting a cabin and you had to rent one for a minimum of 2 days. I reference www.virualtourist.com a lot and heard horror stories of doors that do not lock, feces in cabins, etc... I am not saying all were bad but when I vacation, even for a weekend, I want to not have to worry about "where do I take a shower", or "Where do I get food?" or "Whose cookin?". I did enough "camping" in the Army when stationed in Bosnia... Thanks though
The web site is http://www.hickorygroveretreat.com
The phone number is Toll free at: 1-877-745-0040