Would possibly go back
Overall the Sunday morning trip on the Hel-Cat was a good experience. The two mates were very lively and attentative, although there were a handful of fish that never made it in the boat (not all ours) because the mates were tending to other people, but that is no fault of their own. They fish "The Race" between Block and Fischers island and if you get a very very quick moving tide on the day you are out there the fishing can be kind of tedious. The tide drifted our line away from the boat so quick on most drifts that you could unleash the whole spool and never feel the bottom, which means less chance of landing a fish and more chance of tangles... actually I'd say there was only 2 or 3 drifts where we actually knew we were on the bottom. However, in my party of 4 I caught one mid-sized blue (bigger than cocktail), one caught 5 blues some of pretty decent size, one had a 29" striper and a mid-sized blue, and one caught the pool fish, a 36" striper. So, trip produced some fish, 90% of which were caught before noon, but the drifts started getting way too short in the afternoon, and the tangles and frustrations started mounting. Give it a try and you probably won't be terribly dissappointed.