My oldest brother served 2 years in Milano, and returned 17 different times, eating at actual homes of actual Italians all over the country.
He loves Gloria's Little Italy, and they'll make him any Italian food he asks for, even when not on the menu. The family owners always greet us in Italian and talk to us as long as we want, laughing and telling jokes. When he says it's authentic food, he knows.
My second oldest brother is a 5 star chef, who traveled to Italian homes with my oldest brother to taste the food and meet the people. When he says it's authentic, well-prepared, and high quality for the cost and style, he knows what he's talking about.
I've brought dates off their missions here, they love the food and family also.
It's a Trattoria, not a bakery, and not 5-star dining (which doesn't exist in the food illiterate, cheap state of Utah). Prices are meant to be lower, food is meant to be more modest, like you'd eat at an actual home in Italy.
America does not have the same quality ingredients available for purchase (cost-effective or otherwise) that Italy and Europe do. Nothing you taste in America, especially Provo, will taste as fresh and as rich, because even if they order from the same suppliers, the shipping times automatically reduce freshness. Still, they offer a very high quality for a very low cost.
New York Italian is not Italian, (sorry Serban/Mihnea) - the owners are from Pisa, not the upper east side. "European" is not Italian. They're nothing like the French; they do things their own way, which doesn't mean following the advice of pasta-themed romanian diners (You clearly don't know any Italians.)
The bread: pizze (when served) and panini bread are baked fresh daily, taste delicious. The sliced bread with olive oil isn't "wal-mart" bread, by a long shot, and is comparable to any american establishment, especially for a trattoria.
I am chronically ill, and have problems eating, unable to keep food down. I always feel better when eating at this restaurant, and they willingly accommodate vegetarian and gluten-free diets. I never get sick; their ingredients are always fresh, and healthy, daily - and the minestrone is
Ask any missionary who spent a few years in Italy - typical Americans need to let their taste-buds "defrost" to really enjoy the food, because the typical American diet is loaded up with salt, fat, butter, and sugar.
They use Olive Oil, never butter; these "reviewers" have no idea what they're talking about.
Anybody complaining about the "inauthentic" "cheap" bread needs to research how Pisa is in Tuscany. Look up Pane Toscano (bread from tuscany). It's simple, basic, sliced, and looks just like what they serve and bake daily at Little Italy. Yes, it's authentic.
Morons. Keep telling the family from Pisa that they can't serve food from their home land and be "authentic." They'll know what I know - you're ignorant.
This is easily the best restaurant in Utah County, from appetizer to dessert.