Arrived at the new location down by the Snake River, expected an experienced staff and a good steakhouse. Neither seemed to be present. Arrived for a 30 minute wait outside, good signs of a productive place, so I thought. Once seated, spent another 30 minutes waiting for my order to be taken. Upon arrival of the house salad, I found it to be rather rushed together. For the price of the meal, this was an immediate concern. My hopes continued to vanish as my meal arrived minus the backed potato I had ordered. I was told that they are out. Rather a surprise given that it is Idaho, Land of the potato, and there is also a Walmart full of them, just down the street. The steak was rather rushed together, showing signs of yet again cut corners in the back of house. They substituted in another side, that seemed clearly nuked in a microwave. The whole experience was a definite disappointment. Signs of a restaurant that just can't cut it with a full house. Waiters seemed confused and at odds with messages from the back of house. Clearly some large issues of communication. It was overall an extremely disappointing meal for the hugely priced cost of the ticket. Certainly not competitive with other steakhouse options around town who charge similar or even cheaper tickets. Stockman's was willing to comp the ticket, something I refused. It seemed to be a rehearsed line to wash their hands of poor service. Additionally, I was later told that potatoes were in fact not out, but just behind in baking. An option that was not presented initially, which means they either do not talk to the back of house, or it was a clean cut lie. Very disappointing it was to be a hopeful and promising night of enjoyment. I will not return...
Would not recommend going on a Saturday at 2:30 PM when only about 10 people were there. I ordered their signature peppercorn and bleu cheese steak. It did arrive about 10 minutes later, but unfortunately I did not get either my salad nor my bread. I had been forgotten. I had her take my steak back since she had to go get my salad and break and I did not want to eat a cold steak.
When my steak came, it was medium with virtually not redness inside, not medium rare like ordered (per the guidelines inside their menu. I suspect the oven was used because even my steak knife was hot to the touch.
Yes the steak was good, but the service was very much lacking.
It was Horrible! They sat us at the very top were it was cold and we had our Grandmother with us who had a hard time on the stairs, even though they had open tables in other areas. When we asked for something else they said that is all they had. I ordered the sirloin steak medium rare it was tough and bland and overcooked. They charged my sister 7.99 for a side of kids fries. The waiter was rude and rushed us threw our dinner. Never go there, I certainly won't make that mistake again.
This is the best Steak House Ever, absolutely amazing steaks! When I first heard about this place it sounded to good to be true, all you can eat sirloin steak? had to be cafeteria style or something low quality, nope these are the best sirloins you will ever eat! the first one that comes out is a huge 16oz steak with the Perfect amount of searing on the outside and nice and pink in the middle, if you can get through the first steak for some reason the seconds are always even better! Dont be a wuss get the ALL YOU CAN EAT! My best is 5 steaks, can you beat that? WHat!?!?
I love the decor at Stockmans, table cloths and a gorgeous fireplace make this place just perfect for my wife and I on our date night. Did I mention the food and service are top notch and the Cheesecake is to die for.
Excellent foot good service. A perfect place to go for a juicy, tender stake done just the way you want it. My husband and I love it. We go there at least three times a month on the average. It's a nice surprise when we get the bill and it's way lower than it should be. Give it a try and you'll find yourself going back.
My family and I went to Stockman's last night and had by far the best dinner in a long time. We had the Rancher Burger and it was very very very good, the BBQ sauce was sweet and smooth, definitly a great hamburger, my brother had the Blackened Cajun Sirloin and it was out of the world good. Prime rib was great too. The service was great, the greeter was nice and our waitress was really great and friendly too. We are from Preston, ID and would definitly make the drive again to eat there.