Horribly designed building, OK collection
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 7/20/10
Having visited the old Walker years ago, I was curious to see how the Herzog de Meuron addition meshed with the old space. I can only say that both the site planning and overall design of the new building are horrible. Rather than making thoughtful use of the large grounds, the architects chose to perch the addition about twenty feet from the busiest street in Minneapolis. There is no way of easily dropping off or picking up someone, and there is no cohesive or comfortable outdoor space to welcome visitors. If you drive, you must pull into the parking ramp. This is the most attractive part of the addition, and indeed, it takes up all of the prime space right in the center of the Walker's main property, exactly where the new galleries should have been placed.
When entering the building from the parking ramp, there is a stair and an elevator. One is only on the periphery of the space, and has to go to the first floor. There, nothing is laid out in a way that is friendly to users. There is no central entrance space (as there was in the old Walker), just a low-ceilinged corridor with the ticket vendors tucked into awkward wall niches. One has to wonder what they were thinking, and if it's just a case of a midwestern museum being bullied into a bad design by the Tate Modern's celebrity architects. Hopefully the museum will get another addition in 20 or 30 years, with new architects who can transform the space into something more hospitable and inviting for the community.
If you're into contemporary art, they have a good permanent collection and a nice variety of stuff to see. If that's your bag, you'll want to see for yourself. If you're more interested in architecture, it might be worth a trip to the U of M campus to see the Gehry designed Weisman museum. More humble, but it's a little gem.