Very poor experience
By A Yahoo! Contributor, 9/5/07
My friend and I ate at Schellenger's on Sunday night. The service was awful. The food wasn't much better. The Manhattan Clam Chowder was very salty, the house dressing was bland, the flounder was dry and flavorless, and the crab cakes were mushy and unseasoned.
The service was poor. We ordered water to drink, which were served in baby glasses. The waiter never returned to ask if we needed any more to drink during the meal. I had to walk to the wait station, and grab a pitcher of water. We left a $5 tip, but my friend was afraid it wasn't enough. He was in line before me to get change for more tip, but the cashier reached past him to get the check and money in my hand, completely ignoring him.
I would avoid this place at all costs. The reviewers who said the meal was fantastic either work there or have never had decent seafood before.
We dined at Schellenger's Restaurant on Sunday, September 2, 2007. All the junk on the top of the building is a trap for tourists.