If you like old fashioned type custard instead of just the usual soft ice cream you will -love- this out of the way sort of ice cream/custard stand. Granted there are no bathrooms but its so small that there wouldn't be any place to put them anyway. They have at least 30+ varieties of both hard and soft ice cream and a few specialty flavors during the year, made with fresh local raspberries, strawberries and they have the nicest staff that can make recommendations. My wife and I make a point to go there when we're in or near the area, and have never had a bad experience there.
They also have freshly made ice cream cakes in a small freezer just to the left as you enter the door, a very nice variety and you can get custom work done too.