A short report from an Erie native and former employee...
For a good chunk of my life it has been the only park I've ever been to. I've lived in Erie all my life, so that's not strange. I plan on seeing other parks, but I don't think any of them will give me the happy feeling Waldameer does. Maybe because I grew up going there?
I also worked there for a summer, which was decidedly tiring and stressful. In the end, I realized how cool-headed and tolerant you had to be to work there. If you're easily intimidated or generally unobservant, you're probably going to be labeled "a bad employee." So don't be quick to judge--it's a handful to work there.
This is a good, clean, and visually appealing park, with lot's of trees and benches along the way, as well as having beautiful views of the lake and the city. It's relaxing just to walk in (admission is free) and have a picnic. The prices are still very cheap (around $22 for the all-day combo pass, which is a bargain against individual tickets, lemme tell ya...)
The rides are classic and are in very good condition. Rides are maintained every morning. They usually ride very smoothly, and have that lovely grease smell park enthusiasts love. They monitor the weather closely, and when problems occur, maintenance is quick to act. Everything is usually maintained very well.
My only bad review is for Kiddie Land-
Beware Kiddie Land unless you are watching your children CLOSELY: some of the restraints are loose (or lacking) and employees aren't responsible for taking them off the ride (contrary to popular belief.) Beware the Mini-E if your child likes to move around: the restraints do next to nill for safety. If your kid doesn't stay seated, there's a great chance for an accident.
Waldameer is the fourth-oldest park in PA and the 11th-oldest in the USA. It was leased as Waldameer in 1896. The name literally translates to "Woods by the Sea" in German. It features two Bill Tracy dark rides; the Whacky Shack and the Pirates' Cove. With many other classic rides still standing, and evermore new rides being built, the park is steadily growing both physically and becoming more well-known.
I give it a 5/5 for everything because any problems with the park depend on time of year, weather, and change every day. Every park has that problem. But the park itself is wonderful. I love it. So come visit!