My husband and I went to try Anthony's based on all of the great reviews and word of mouth. We had an easy time getting reservations only a few hours before dinner and when we arrived we found they have free valet service that allows you to pull right up to the door. It seemed to be a very busy restaurant, and with that said it seemed like the kitchen was either behind in making dinners for everyone or they just take their time. The service we had was great when we first got to the restaurant, however, we never got our appetizer that we asked for, and I attribute most of this to the waitress we had, she didn't seem to listen well. The atmosphere was great, the waiters came around and filled the water glasses all the time which was nice and the beer selection on tap was fantastic.
I think the night would have been better if I hadn't spent $100 on food and drink to have a waitress that didn't seem attentive to us and it would have been great to not have to wait 10 minutes for the check. The Lummi Salmon that I had was wonderful, the potatoes they serviced with it were very bland and rather undercooked and the fish my husband had was great, but again the potatoes were bland.
All in all I think the restuarant was great and the food was good as well, and I really believe our experience would have been 5 stars had the waitress been a bit more professional and attentive.