An honest review from a non-local.
By notscott, 10/15/07
Half Moon Bay is a charming city. I have always wanted to go to this festival and this year, we finally made the trip. We had a GREAT time, but if you're expecting something different, you may be a bit disappointed. The fair consists of the typical booths of arts and crafts and while there are many nice things, you can find similar items at the many other seaside festivals along the California Coast. The huge pumpkins make it a little different and it's interesting to watch Farmer Mike carve one of the giants.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying it's not worth the trip up--it is--just go for the entire weekend experience, not just the fair. Stay at the Ritz Carlton, go have the pancake breakfast at the fair, look at the arts and crafts and go pumpkin hunting when you're done at the various farms. Check out the farms South of Half Moon Bay on Highway 1 for farms that are less crowded and have petting zoos and mazes.
We will absolutely go here again.
My biggest tip for this fair is to ARRIVE WHEN THEY OPEN!!!! An incredible amount of people go to this thing. If your hotel offers shuttle service to the fair--TAKE IT! It will save you lots of time and energy searching for parking. Lastly, go WITH the flow when you make your way around the fair--it will make your visit much more pleasant.
Enjoy!