J Butler Collection (The), Nantucket

While most of the antique furnishing concerns on Nantucket are on the pricey side, The J Butler Collection is surprisingly affordable without sacrificing any of the quality. The place has a casual, homey atmosphere; indeed, it is run out of the house of the owners. You can shop in comfort, without any hard-sell from a salesman. Of course, you may want to apply a little elbow grease to the door; it sticks. But it's worth the effort.