Its the bar everyone should want!
My wife and I don't drink, but she allowed me to make the trek to Sloppy Joes because of its Hemingway heritage and the relatively good buzz from those who were at our hotel.
It was loud as hell, as any good bar leading up to Memorial Day weekend should be off Duval Street. The waitresses were friendly and quick to refill our drinks and check in on our food. The food is bar food, but pretty tasty bar food. PLEASE HAVE THE SLOPPY JOE! It was great, and I don't usually even have a manwich if I can avoid it. It was a Friday night and there was some live music. The performers involved as much of the bar as they could and the bar staff played along without ever losing track of any of the patron's needs (being someone who works with people, I took special notice of this).
Just a fun time.