This new comer is the BEST on Island - service, eh
The wonderful wine list and delicious deserts where dwarfed by the flavorful entrees. I had the Halibut and my wife had the scallops. Both dishes where unbelievably tasty. Can't wait to go back to Shelter Island so I can dine here again soon.
Only issue was the steak was not cooked as order by one of my guests. He asked for the steak to be med-rare (actually originally asked for it med-well, but the server convinced him to go for mid-rare), and the steak was served blood-red / purple. When brought to the attention of the server, he gave us a free drink and free desert, but still charged us for the meal.