Nice little place, good, original flavors, and very creamy, tasty gelato. I stop by every time I'm in the area. It's especially nice if you're in the late afternoon eating in their tables outside in the back. Bathrooms are outside and hard to get to, but the quibble's so inconsequential that there's no star lost IMHO.
3.5 actually. Although this place will satisfy your fix for gelato, I've had far better gelato elsewhere. My wife and I find most of their flavors too sweet and the texture is not as creamy as others we've had. However, the last time I was there I had the Amaretto Almond and it was really good, again a bit too sweet, but the flavor was great with tiny chopped almonds for a nice crunch.