As far as I know the food is consistently good, the staff charming and the atmosphere is your standard cute hole in the wall place.
I love going there since I know where I come from there aren't any restaurants like this one.
I don't know where the other reviewers are eating but it can't be the same place I am. I have been eating here for years, and it is always a treat, the portions are generous and the food very well cooked. The meat dishes are especially good and never fatty! I would recommend the Grecian Cafe to anyone looking for a break from the usual take-out fare. Friendly service too. Not much ambiance as restaurants go but most of their business is take out. If you like Greek food that does not run to the exotic you will enjoy the Grecian Cafe. Oh and the side dish rice is excellent some of the best I have had anywhere at any price.
If I could've given this place negative stars, I would have! Ever since Grecian cafe renovated their restaurant, the food has become exceptionally bad. Though the people who work there are still really nice and its a nice little place, the Gyros plate is about half the size of what it used to be, and the avgolemono soup is so loaded with eggyolk that its basically an artery clogger in a bowl. You might as well enjoy a hot piping serving of overpriced cholesterol.
I used to be a regular here, but will no longer be frequenting Grecian Cafe with its sparse portions of meat and overloaded bowls of fat. I'm really sad because this used to be one of the best greek restaurants around.