Good Italian restaurants vs. good pizza
I lived fairly close to Palermo's location for several years but it never came up in conversation when friends were looking for good pizza. Most of the 4 and 5 star reviews seem to stress the overall ambience, service, and menu choices and that's fine. Some day, I'll be happy to give it a try. However, when the selection comes down to actual pizza, I have to agree that Casa Bianca is about the best in the city. Yes, other than the pizza itself, Casa B. is somewhat overrated - the other menu items tend to be average at best, and the weekend waiting time is horrendous. What makes it special (I think), and why many will endure that wait, is primarily the tomato sauce they use on the pizza. Judging from my Northern New Jersey background, I can tell this is an authentic New York area pizza sauce recipe. Combined with an excellent crust, this is best I've had on the West Coast. Unless you are from the New York area, it is unlikely you have developed the proper taste buds for great Italian-American pizza, so anything well made will do.