Craigo's Gourmet Pizza Company, Rexburg

This excellent pizza restaurant is now called Pizza Pie Cafe. They have an awesome pizza buffet and many unique offerings for the whole family.

BEST PIZZA EVER!!! great service and great price!!!! IF YOU AE IN IDAHO YOU HAVE TO GO!!!

Good pizza, not the greatest prices on menu items but an amazing deal for the buffet. Great dessert pizzas and such.

Poor pizza at best. There is very little cheese on pizzas. If you don't believe me try scraping the cheese off. Very little. Lots of crust

I love this pizza place! best pizza and salad bar! And the dessert oreo pizza is the best thing I have ever had! I'd recommend this pizza place to any one and NO I AM NOT AN EMPLOYEE!

Worst Pizza I've EVER had at any price~!!!! I had my hopes up after reading posts on this and other sites... was REALLY LET DOWN!! My jaw was actually sore after having to chew the rock hard pizza pieces... tried the pasta and it was flavorless... tried the dessert pizza DRIED OUT!! I find it hard to believe people find this place good?? It must be owners/workers posting here to bring in more business... trust me NOT GOOD AT ANY PRICE!! I can't believe I'm going to say this but even frozen pizza would have actually been better!!!!! !!!!!! ~!!!!!!

Absolutely amazing taste, the crust is wonderful and the service is great. If I get to choose the place, it will always be Craigo's! I love the all you can eat the most!!

Wonderful Service, Great new location, and wonderful eating environment. I love the pizza! The crust has a superb mixture of taste and texture. I eat here every chance I get. Its not a fancy schmancy resturaunt, but its definately on my favorite restuaunts list.