Probably the most popular hang-out bar and grill in Sheridan, the Pony has that predictable sports bar feel. The bar is well stocked, but draft beers are rather pricey. Food is so-so depending on the dish. Most is typical pub fare, and is not remarkable in any way. If pressed, I would recommend the patty melt with the house potato salad, or the buffalo chicken salad. The large deck is nice in warmer months.
Good stuff guys. Good food, nice atmosphere, clean, smoke free, fair prices/good proportions, fast and friendly service (well staffed), and thumbs up on the micro-brews. If I happen to stop into Sheridan again, the Pony is where I'll eat and socialize.
I typically enjoy eating and drinking at the Pony. The menu is an above average bar menu, and it is nice to have such a large variety of beers on tap. The service can really be hit or miss. Always helpful to have an attractive male at the table to increase likelyhood of waitress attention. Get there about 30 minutes earlier than you want to eat and you should be in the clear. This is a popular place that can sometimes be a little chaotic. It is worth the wait and a little patience.
I had a very bad experience with poor service coupled with a very arogant and rude manager. I will never set foot in this establishment again. I can't comment on the quality of food as after 1 hour the food still wasn't served and the wait would be at least 30 more minutes. Most working people can't take 2 hour lunches!!!
the worst service I have had in the longest time. I have been to 5 states in the past 4 weeks and the PONY made me feel like a criminal. After the first waiterss sat us down. the next 4 servers that same night were cold and very unatentive. I will never go back to this bar & grill. I would recommend McDonalds for better service and attention.
We had to have had the slowest waitress on the planet for our lunch date at the Pony. The food was pretty good, nothing stellar but it was overshadowed by the lax attitude of the waitress. I will go back but only if I can have someone else wait on me.