Black Otter Supper Club, Hortonville

My dad used to own the Black Otter years ago and he had a sign in there that said all my customers make me happy some by coming and others by leaving how true that is Black Otter Supper Club is still the best place in the state and i am happy to say that the ones running it are doing a great job.

The Black Otter Supper Club is one of the best Supper Clubs in the state as far as quality price and service! This year for Christmas we are buying gift cards to the Black Otter instead of buying cheap products from Walmart made in China.

My husband and I met up with some old friends last night at the Black Otter. It was the most awesome meal I have ever had. The service was great and food was even better. I would definately recommend this establishment to everyone. I would like to know where I can purchase the blackened seasoning that you use on your steaks. This seasoning made the already superd cut of meat even better. :)

I travel for work all over the country and I come to New London every year for business trip. My sister drives up from Milwaukee/Brookfield and our favorite place to go is the Black Otter on Tuesday night! We have be doing it for 3 years now and will continue because the price, the quanity ,the service with a smile and hospitality can not be beat! So all you all who are complaining, don't know I good thing when you have it. You would not be getting a meal like the one they serve in New York, New Orleans or even Los Angelos! Keep up the good work, and we will continue to come and enjoy! Mary Hupp (Omaha, NE) and sister Karen (Milwaukee, WI)

Me and my fiance live in Menasha but go out to eat at the black otter when ever we get the chance. You cant beat the prices or the food. We always get the ribeye and fan tail shrimp which is the best shrimp and steak that Iv'e ever had in my life, the steak melts in your mouth. We also love the salad bar with the cheese and crackers. But you have to be careful not to fill up on that otherwise you will be bringing alot of food home. If you have never tryed the Black Otter then you should go check it out you wont be disapointed at all. I cant wait to go back. Thank you Black Otter for the great food and wonderful service.

I've been hearing how good the Black Otter is for decades but, incredibly, tonight was the first time my wife and I went. It's about half an hour away but worth the drive. We were not familiar with their routine, with taking your order at the bar, etc., but we adapted. Fortunately, we had a place to sit at the bar as it was very busy. Still, we didn't feel like we had to wait an unusual amount of time. I can't say enough how friendly everyone was and I liked the good ol' Wisconsin supper club atmosphere. Oh, by the way, we liked the food! My tenderloin turned out to be more than I could eat so I'm looking forward to having the rest with my eggs in the morning. We're looking forward to our next visit and it'll be sooner than later.