Great food, good atmosphere. I've brought several out-of-towners to this place and they went home full and happy. The black bean burgers are fabulous as are the beer battered fries. The have ultra-spicy wings and uniquely Wisconsin nachos. Lots of good local beers on tap as well.
Revisited Hilltop last nite with my father. Had the chicken chimichaga special...and again for lunch today (Huge portions-leftovers for a second meal). Stylish presentation on top a bed of lettuce and colored tortilla chips surrounded by heaping gobs of refried beans covered in cheese, spanish rice, salsa and tomato bits. It was served on 2 plates because you couldn't possible eat it from the mound it was served on. Very visually pleasing. My father had one of the monster hamburgers with fried onions and fruit and we got another to go. Our server was delightful and very attentive and without asking kept us floating in free refills of soda. Always good, reasonably priced, place hops on the weekend.