By far the best pizza we have ever had!!!!!! And the Tortellini Del Mar is out of this world. My husband and I found this little gem of a restaurant when we moved into the area, and have never been disappointed in all the years(8) we have gone there. Glad I found this page today while looking for their phone number to order our stuffed pizza.
4/23/11 We had a very enjoyable family dinner. The atmosphere is very friendly and quiet. We all thought our food tasted wonderful. The portions were very generous and priced reasonably. We enjoyed it and had to take the remainder home to enjoy! We'll be back again.
I have eaten here six times in three years. I think the food is phenominal. Large portions, always fresh, great bread. best Gnocci's I have ever had. It can be a little pricey for the Italian specialties and dinner specials. The basic pasta dishes very affordable. I have always had great service and lots of food to go. It certainly isn't Olive Garden - Thankfully. They need fresh brewed iced tea especially in the summer and on weekends. I wish the dining area was larger as on summer weekends it can be quite busy. What are your other options for good Italian near Silver Lake WI? psst - there aren't any.
A friend told me this restaurant was really good. So, my girlfriend and I checked it out. I thought it was average. I have had better Italian food and I have had worse Italian food. The service was ok.Atmosphere was ok.
The first time we ate there we were sworn to silence not to tell anyone so we could always get a table but we could not help bragging about the food, service, and friendly owners. If you are in the area don't miss going there for a great meal with Linda and Tom the owners and tell them Wayne and Joan said hello and that we'll see them in the spring.
I would like to start off with an apology to the owners and staff of Binanti's Taste of Italy. Although I have known the restaurant was there for several years, I never considered going to Silver Lake for Italian food. MEA CULPA, MEA CULPA, MEA MAXIMA CULPA. What a little gem of a place!! Friendly, clean, reasonably priced, wonderful food, and the portions...oh, the portions. Taking leftovers home allowed me to enjoy my meal all over again the next day. They were fabulous.
I am going back and my family and friends are coming with me.
Love the food here. I have been coming here for years and I love how unique of a place it is. its so not your boring franchize and the prices are totally worth what you get. i love the pasta di casa and when they have briscoule on special I eat the left overs for days!!! The only thing is it is pretty regional, so obviously some of the food (like the pasta vesoul? soup) can be different from other places, but in a good way. I love mom and pop places, and this place makes me feel right at home. I recomend this place to everyone.