Worst place to eat in this county. Not only do they have the worst service, but they have horrible employees. I ordered a pizza over the phone, and went to go pick it up, they had no record of me calling in. So, I drove home and my dad called them back and placed the order again. Then, I left my house again to go pick it up, and the manager came out and was in my face screaming, and yelling about how I am a liar and I didn't place the order.(Neither my dad or I made a fuss about the misunderstanding) And told me he wasn't going to make the pizza.
Sorry, but screaming at your customers? Really? Calling them a liar? They don't even deserve 1 star. Try none.
I've been living in the area for about 7 years and I still don't understand why people consider this to be good pizza. Average at best. The pizza is small, thin, usually has a burnt taste to it and overpriced for what you get. The fact is that there is better pizza in Cedarburg including Romano's and even Sal's (a little hit or miss at Sal's). Even Little Caesar's is better.
The service at Tomaso's is the ABSOLUTE WORST I've ever encountered. Rude, cold, unfriendly, you name it. The jerk working behind the counter isn't qualified for anything requiring human interaction.
Spend your money elsewhere.
the best thin crust I've ever had, by far. If you want to be smoozed by the bartenders this isn't the place for you. If you want good food come and get it. I miss being able to eat here more often, as I have moved to GA where I have yet to find a comparable pizza.
I found this little treasure tucked into the quaint town of Cedarburg my first time traveling from Milwaukee to Cedar Creek settlement. I found the pizza fantastic, as well as the fact you can have a dining experience with no bother of waitstaff. Yes it is a bit small, and tables are together quite close, but I too love the pizza and the appetizers are fantastic. You get a huge amount for a great price. I am presently out of Wisconsin in Pennsylvania for past 3 months. My friend and I can't wait to get home to go to Tomaso's for the food thanksgiving week. Enjoy the food, a place I will enjoy the day after thanksgiving, amen!!!
Don't know how this place is still in business. Food is average. Owner is rude and the food takes forever to come out. When my brother found a hair in his sandwich the owner gave a lame excuse and refused to replace it.
The decor is old and dirty. Don't waste your time.
I tried the thin crust pizza years ago and loved it so much that I haven't had anything else on the menu. The pizza is great. I would eat there everyday if I could.
The restaurant itself is cramped and dimly lit. The restaurant was full one day and we had to sit at one of the middle tables and it was terrible. People bump into you because there is about 2' of walking space on either side of you. You must sit at a booth to be comfortable.
The whole experience is awkward if you are a first timer. You seat yourself and go up to the bar to order. Some bartenders seem annoyed if you don't know the rules. One in particular can be rude and always seems bothered no matter what.
That being said, as long as you can get a booth I would highly recommend Tomaso's just because their pizza is so good.