Not a place to visit again. Service was poor with multiple errors on the order despite the lack of any crowded conditions. The Rustic Steak salad was one of the poorest combination of ingredients I've ever tasted. The steak was extremely chewy, the potatoes were only half cooked, the button mushrooms were nothing but a couple of mushroom pieces and one of the pizzas was blackened on much of the crust. The 18% gratuity added for our party of 5 must have encouraged the waitress to really slack off as the service didn't warrant 10% at best.
This has to be the best meal I had in all of New Buffalo. White Bean soup was spectacular and the Salmon with balsamic reduction was cooked to perfection. We went around 5 o'clock and there was a twenty minute wait, we were seated sooner than that but it was really crowded when we left. Go early and you'll have no complaints. Terrific food.
A terrible experience for a large party. We did have a reservation, but they made it seem like we were infringing and they didn't want us in their establishment. I now have 25 people that will not go back to Brewsters.
Hmmmm Hit and Miss. Long service wait. One salad dressing to choose from. Limited choices for a vegetarian. I don't think I get my money's worth. I visit occasionally, what I can order is usually good, but not great.
We have been here many times. While things can & do happen which will affect your experience, the overall rating I give Brewsters is 4 1/2 stars. If you come with expectations of a european restaurant dining experience, primarily where TIME is considered, they are average. For most people born in the good ole US of A, this means not seeing your waiter/es for extended periods of time is NORMAL. Where food & atmosphere are concerned they have rarely if ever been disappointing in any way. To put it another way, this explains why we drive 45 miles one way to Brewesters whenever we can spare the time.
Very quaint Italian restaurant where the menu changes every day. In the summer expect to wait, but it's worth it. Have never had a bad meal for lunch or dinner. Wood fired oven pizza's are excellent, and couldn't get enough of the spinach dip appetizer.
Even when there is not vegan food on the menu (it changes frequently, and there is alway vegetarian), you can always count on fabulous pizzas you can design with so many vegan options. They are delicious, above delicious, more like euphoric, and the salad is just as enthusiastic. You have to go get some zen!
This was my second visit to Brewsters. Just as good as the first time. The decor is wonderful, the atmosphere is romantic and the food is to die for. Offering outdoor garden seating or indoor, you can choose from the best of both worlds. They also offer a dinner for two which is exquisite - Salad, pizza, entree and cookies for $32.99.
This is an excellent italian restaurant with a romantic atmosphere. You can dine in the lovely garden or inside. Don't forget to try their wonderful iced tea. They also have an on site bakery where you can purchase the most wonderful muffins!
I ENJOYED THE FOOD THE WAIT WAS LITTLE LONG AND WHEN WE WERE SEATED WE DID NOT SEE OUR SERVER FOR SOME TIME WHEN I DID ORDER ( PASTA WITH CLAMS AND MUSSLES) OVER HALF OF THE CLAMS WERE NOT OPENED MEANING THEY WERE BAD( DEAD) TOLD THE SERVER SHE SAID SHE WOULD TELL THE CHEF. JUST THINK I DID NOT GET ALL MY MONEY WORTH. MIGHT GO BACK ONE MORE TIME TO TRY IT. MAYBE THE CHEF AND THE SERVER HAD A BAD DAY???
Amenities:Refrigerator. Kitchen/Kitchenette. Television. DVD/VCR. Television (Cable/Satellite). Daily Maid Service. Microwave Oven. Air Conditioning (In Room). Non Smoking Rooms. Hotel Details:14
Rooms / 1 Floors. Built in 1952. Smoke Alarm in Rooms. Pool (Outdoor).
O'Brien Inn is conveniently located at Exit 1 off I 94 in the southwest corner of Michigan, one mile from
the Indiana/Michigan state line. The hotel is in close proximity to Chicago and Notre Dame University in South Bend, ...
The Holiday Inn Express Suites New Buffalo is located 1 mile from downtown New Buffalo, and 35 miles from the
Michigan Regional Airport, 80 miles from the Midway Airport and 100 miles from the Chicago Ohare Airport. Local attractions ...