Welcome to the New Bethel Ordinary. Located in the heart of downtown Wanamaker, the Ordinary has grown to become a popular dining destination for ... More
New Bethel Ordinary
Welcome to the New Bethel Ordinary. Located in the heart of downtown Wanamaker, the Ordinary has grown to become a popular dining destination for people from all over Central Indiana. The Ordinary has always strived to maintain a small-town appeal, serving great food and drinks in a casual family friendly atmosphere. The Ordinary is open at 7:00 a.m. daily to serve you a full cooked-to-order breakfast. We offer daily lunch and dinner specials, as well as cost-friendly Kid's and Seniors menu. Friday and Saturday nights we still feature our 12 ounce grilled prime rib dinner. The signature item of the Ordinary is our Pizza. Try a 10 or 16 inch pizza, each made to order, using only the freshest ingredients and baked in our traditional style brick ovens. The pizza is available daily at 10:00 a.m. for dine-in or carry-out. In a hurry - these same great pizzas are now available for take and bake.
I drive from Greenfield to get this pizza because it's SOOOOOOOOO good and has a lot of toppings. I've told several other people about them an they are hooked on them Too . They now have take N bake ,so if you have a long way to go,,you can just pop it in the oven when you get home !
No doubt, in the top 2 pizza's in the entire city,with baxbeaux being right there.But you have to go to broad ripple or downtown for it.They have many other good items on the menu,the breaded tenderloin,prime rib,and the daily lunch specials,are all very good.They keep raising their prices,so sadly we have scaled back on our number of visits.One other knock on the place is it's crowded,cramped dining room, and the 4 foot by 4 foot restrooms(I measured them).I really don't see how it passes for the handicapped.The whole building is old and falling apart, with terrible parking conditions.A move to another bigger building would increase business for sure.That is why we always order carryout early on a weekend evening to avoid the whole parking mess.
I live on the Northwest side of Indianapolis, and I travel all the way over to Wanamaker to get one of the biggest and most delicious oversized pizzas of all time. It's the best pizza I ever had. It's well worth the drive.
Nice local bar/restaurant with decent food but nothing I'm gonzo over EXCEPT for the Bread Pudding. It's to die for and the sole reason I make a point to drop in now and again. Of course, the recipe's a secret so I'll just have to keep coming back.
Hidden in the small town of Wannamaker you’ll find the best pizza in the Midwest. My family and I would drive to Chicago to the famous Giordano’s Pizzeria. Not any more. They have that family friendly feeling that you just don’t find in any big city. We found a new pizza destination that’s worth the drive.
*Terms & Conditions: Savings calculation is based on Flight + Hotel vacation package bookings for a 3 month period for 2 adults with a 2+ night length of stay compared to price of the same components if booked separately during same period. Savings will vary based on origin/destination, length of trip, travel dates and selected travel supplier(s). Savings not available on all packages.