Good food and great value
This is one of my favorite restaurants in downtown Indy. They have a good assortment of Italian meals always prepared to consistent quality in the 20-plus times I've been there. Their wine selection is good, but not on par with the food. Beer selection is an outright disappointment, aside from Guinness, all their selection is made of pale-water style beers, mostly domestic lights.
The food quality paired with the medium cost of dining makes Bertolini's a great value.