this pizza is the best.my uncle told us how good it was and wew didnt believe him so we went.needless to say weve been going ever since for five years even though it takes about 45 minutes but its worth it.there blt is to die for and there subs are alwsome.my only complaint is the tables are small but its worth it for that heavenly taste
Pizza on a summmer night or winter night.The Pizza Cottage is still one of the best pizza around .Being from columbus and moveing to buckeyelake in 1990 I wonder what the pizza would be like moveing out here...Then a co-worker told me about the Pizza Cottage and then 15 years later same great taste .....When cat fish charlie came to buckeyelake I had to try it well never the less I would not let my dog eat it the meat ball sub is dry no taste and the pizza needs a face lift for taste ....So Pizza Cottage your number # 1
Raymond and Sherri Anderson of buckeyelake
The pizza is good in small amounts but it soooo greasy. If you take one slice of their pizza and press down on top of it with a couple napkins , you'll pull away the napkin VERY wet.
There service IS wonderful. Even when it's right after a football game and people are lined up you still get excellent service.
I love the pizza so much! we order every friday night, the italian subs are awesome and I really like the cheddar bacon pizza. The staff are so great. One time we walked in as they were locking the doors but they let us in to dine anyway. I enjoy my experience everytime I'm there!