I went there a total of 4 times so far. My first time was the best. Jamie waited on me and was a real sweetie. Her service was awesome, my pizza was great, and she seemed to really like the fact that I was enjoying Fort Myers.
My second time there was not quite as good as my then-favorite waitress (Jamie) was not there. But at least Lori was there, she remembered me vvery clearly, and she was just as nice. And apparently, she even encouraged me to send Jamie a Facebook friend request, which I did (but unfortunately she did not accept it).
My third time was about average. The restaurant was crowded, but I still got my food.
My 4th time there was not good. My (ex-favorite) waitress (Jamie) was there, but unfortunately she was acting very standoffish and rather gangsterous, which made me rather uncomfortable, basically as if she were about ready to go totally sour or something at any second. This time, I had a male waiter, and apparently his service was rather fast paced, which was good because this time, I was sort of looking forward to getting out of there before Jamie would have gone sour on me.
We ate here based on good reviews beware! It was 80 outside & 85 inside. Waitress was rude, had a pizza & calzone both undercooked inside but burnt on the outside. Worst food we had our whole vacation.
Once upon a time, Island Pizza was really good. But then, it changed owners, and first they changed the cheese, then they changed how they processed other ingredients, such as the green peppers. The result was a disappointment, and we stayed away for nearly a year. Last weekend, we tried them again. Unfortunately, it was even worse than before. They bought a great pizza business, then little by little, devalued the product. We won't be going back there again. Ever.
If you are looking for a good Pizza place on Sanibel Island, then this will do the job! There pizza good and service is good. Over all I would have to say it's good. I wouldn't say it's OMG lets go here every night, but it does a good job to fill you up.
This place was perfect. Service, food, not to mention the food! Our server was wounderfull and the owners are very friendly. perfect island restaurant, great food, and good prices... i would deffently reccomend this place!!!
The Pizza is very good and authentic here...the antipasto salad is very good too....this is one of our favorite casual places on the Island to eat. The owner's are very friendly and helpful too...some of the best Pizza around.
Settled directly on the soft, white sand shore of the Gulf of Mexico, Shalimar is an Old Florida style resort
of 33 units, offering fun and relaxation in a peaceful, pristine atmosphere. Whether you wish to celebrate a romantic ...
Song of the Sea is a 30 room intimate European style inn located on Sanibel Island directly on the Gulf
of Mexico and 19 miles from the Southwest Florida International Airport. Spacious West Indies style rooms and suites feature ...
The sparkling white beaches of Sanibel Island are world famous for their abundance of unusual seashells. Water sport choices abound
on the island, including windsurfing, fishing, sailing, boat rentals, and canoeing. Our huge pool and tennis court on five ...