Di Maggio's Pizzeria, Winter Haven

This is the best Pizza around, hands down! This coming from a New Yorker that just moved to Florida.

we are from new york orginally and were thrilled to find an authentic pizzeria.we never buy any other pizza. the sauce, cheese and seasonings are wonderful

If you are a New Yorker in your heart & miss a little bit of home..Well you have it here. Step back into New York and enjoy the best pizza around. Others try to fool you, chains & those who add other types of cheeses. When you find home cooking. Awesome. I grew up in NY, worked in my Dad's Italian restaurant & Just like Poppa used to make. Thank You DiMaggio's for being hee in Florida. If I could give it more than 5 stars I would.

It's been a while since the last review but DiMaggio's is still the BEST pizza around

I no longer get pizza from anywhere else. I'm repeating the other reviews, but it bears repeating: this pizza rivals the best nyc's little italy has to offer. The cheese is fantastic and there's plenty of it. The sauce is rich and not too sweet. The bread is magnificent.

I don't see how anyone can get pizza anywhere else this is the real thing. The best in Florida so far real New York, even better sometimes. Just the best

Good does not even begin to describe this pizza. I was in NY a few months back and my gf told me we were going to have REAL NY pizza one night. I told her I can have real NY pizza anytime I want in WH. She laughed. Frankly I was not impressed with the pizza we got. Then she came to visit this summer. I told her one night that we were going to have real NY pizza, and ordered the Special and a Cheese pizza from Dimaggios. After eating it she had to agree that Dimaggios blew her pizza away. Get the special, even if you dont like the toppings, pull off what you dont like. Its fabulous. We dont eat peppers and I tried ordering it without but it just wasnt as good. So now we order the special and remove the things we dont eat. Dimaggios is made from scratch and it rocks!

WOW!!! ALL I CAN SAY IS WOW.. THE BEST PIZZA IN TOWN!!!! I HAVE A FAMILY OF 5 AND ALWAYS ASKS FOR DI MAGGIO'S PIZZA OVER ANY OTHER.....

If your from the North-East (NY, NJ) you'll be at home with the pizza from Dimaggio's. I have been in the area 20 years and this takes back home. If you want something other than a pizza, try the meatball sub's, the calzone or any of the other items on the menu. I Love This Place.

I love the pizza there, it's absolutey yummy. It's the way pizza should taste.