New York Pasta Garden, Key West

This is one of the finest dining experiences in Key West. I love the ambiance--little white lights wrapped around the huge trees, white table cloths and napkins, outdoor candlelight. The service is excellent and the food delicious. We have been back several times and will continue to go to try different dishes. We have had seafoood, veal, fish, chicken and all were great!!

3/5/11 - I took my 11 year old here for a more elegant dining experience and to try a couple of seafood dishes. We ordered stuffed lobster tail, shrimp fettuccine alfredo and spaghetti and meatballs for a backup dish. As it turned out the lobster and shrimp were wonderful but we didn't care for the spaghetti and meatballs. Go figure! The atmosphere was very romantic and relaxing. We ate outside and there were lots of white lights strung in and around the trees and foliage. What a lovely touch! The service was very good and very friendly. A very enjoyable evening.

This was the worst dinning experience I've had in Key West. Maybe we caught them on a bad. It was not crowded. At one point we were the only ones there yet waited over an hour for our food. When it arrived, it was cold. The waiter ignored us and actually sent the DISH WASHER out to refill our coffee. The entire experience was ridiculous. A shamefull display of bad business.

The location is slightly off Duval. Ask any local resident and they can tell you where it is located. We had both lunch and dinner during our stay in Key West and both meals were absolutely excellent. We are used to good Italian food in Chicago and it was an unexpected surprise. Also try the garlic dinner rolls served before your meal, They are WONDERFUL, we had to request more which they gladly provided. When we are back in Key West we will be back to this restaurant.

My husband and I stumbled up on this restaurant after our third consecutive visit to Key West. The menu offered many choices, and the food was out of this world. The service was exceptional, no matter how busy the staff was. The portions are quite large, so bring a major appetite. The staff will also accomodate your suggestions! This place is worth visiting. Attire can be casual or upscale. The best Italian food I have EVER had!!!!

Truly one of THE best dining experiences in Key West or anywhere else! Michael, the Proprietor was friendly and hospitable - very accommodating to us and every other diner at his restaurant. The outdoor dining had a lovely casual atmosphere with white linen table cloths and softly lit trees. Our party of six thought the service was outstanding and the food absolutely superb! Thank you for a fabulous dining experience Michael - we'll be back!

we had a little wedding reception there and everything was sooo awesome.the owner michael was super accomedating seeing that wwe only gave him 5 hours notice for 30 people. thanks for a wonderful night. the food was out of this world and the staff was great thanks again

The food is excellent, the menu selections are extensive with some original recipes and the atmosphere is very relaxed and casual. My husband and I will go there again before we leave Key West.