My wife and I visited Pizzalley's yesterday to listen to their music and enjoy their happy hour. It is from 3pm till 6pm. I understood from a previous visit that the beers were 2 for 1 and the 10 inch pizza was buy one get one free. I was half correct according to the waitress (who by the way had most of her body tatoo). She said the 10 inch pizza was half price with a round of drinks. We had to purchase a second round of beer at the happy hour price to receive the 2 pizzas at half price. Since we had already ordered 2 garbage can pizzas, we ordered the second round of drinks. For $2.50 more the waitress was able to discount our bill by $6.00. This did not make sense to us since we bought more and paid less. We did not need the extra beers nor did we want them. We only ordered them because it cost less in total by doing the extra beer. It would have been better for them to discount the second pizza the same as the waiter had done 3 nights before. They could have saved the beer and sold it to a customer that was willing to pay the price.
We also had a problem getting the waitress to bring us refills of water and the free slice of pizza that goes with the order of beer during happy hour. She finally brought the free slice as we were half way through our ordered pizza. Not good timing. We also had a 10% discount coupon that the manager would not honor because of getting the pizza at the reduced happy hour price. It did not say on the coupon it could not be used with other offers. They also honored the coupon 3 days earlier when we were there. I am having a problem about going back for another try. We have been there 3 times in the last week and 2 of the 3 visits were good. The last one may have convinced me that I need to stay away in the future.