Pizzalley's, St Augustine

BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD!!!!! My husband and I travel from Indiana to St. Augustine every year and this is the first place we eat EVERY TIME!! We have eaten in the restuarant part and the smaller dining room off St. George. Both are great! We love going to happy hour where you get two for one drinks and a free slice of pizza! We eat here several times during our stay. I have had pizza everywhere including Rome and it doesn't compare to the great pizza that Pizzalley's serves! The only thing that could make this better is if there was one closer to Indiana! We are going down in September of this year and we can't wait to get our yearly dose of awesome pizza!!

I was not very impressed about the pizza. The kids seemed to really like it, but the price and the wait were not worth it. I know I have seen reviews that state it is one of the best pizza's in St Augustine, but I do not agree. We ate at Pizza Hut 2 years ago and I think the pizza's there tasted better. The next time we go I will look for some other local pizza place to try.

Great pizza - awesome entertainment for children (or maybe it was just an extra special employee that day...) Would go back, for sure.

Best place to eat pizza in America ever!!!!!! and they have free samples.... how can you possibly beat that??

Great atmosphere with outdoor seating. The pizza was great and the kids enjoyed the place as well. The staff ensures you have a great visit and be sure to try the create your own pasta dish.

After two people in one week told me the best pizza they ever ate was at Pizzalley in St. Aug. I decided to head down and try it - THEY WERE RIGHT!! What great pizza - I have not had any that good in Jacksonville!

We visit St. Augustine frequently and loved eating at Pizzalley's on their outside deck with our little dog. Unfortunately, the last two times we were in town, they told us that we couldn't have our dog there - on the outside deck. Subsequently, we found another pizza spot on King St. called Flavors that has fabulous pizza AND graciously welcomes our little hairy family member. Being a dog lover, I'll go out of my way to support a business that allows dogs. I'm surprised when a restaurant has outdoor seating yet doesn't allow dogs. That's just me.

While working this wonderful midnight shift. And my left eye begining to twitch due to over working myself. I can truly say I could go for a Godfather pizza and tasty breadstick and a gallon of Sweet tea. Hope all is well T and C

We tried Pizzalley for lunch on our first afternoon in the city. We both had the lasagna and it was excellent. The waiter was helpful even giving us directions to another restaurant we wanted to try. We enjoyed sitting out back on the porch facing Charlotte Street. It was cool but they had the outdoor heaters working. It was a restaurant we would go back to.

We love this pizza restaurant! Everytime we visit St. Augustine, stopping at Pizzalley's for lunch is a must.