This is my baseline pizza! I compare every other pie that I eat to it... and very few measure up. I would put Vinnie's in Savannah and a handful of places in NYC on the same level but none above it! The sauce is wonderful, toppings are great, the draft beer is cheap (and usually cold) - it's everything you could want from a college pizza bar!
I'm giving this three stars because their pizza is really THAT average. I mean, I'm from NYC and this isn't anything like what they advertise. I think Mellow Mushroom is better than this. It beats chain store places like Papa Johns (which isn't even pizza...that's just bread with sauce and cheese on it). It's not too shabby but it's sure not home.