I feel as though this place has gotten too cocky for itself. It used to be nice to get a NY style pizza every now and then as a change from the normal pizza chains. And being that the NY pizza is their biggest draw, I can see why so many people rate them positively. However the service sucks and truthfully the quality of food leaves much to be desired. Ive tried on multiple occasions to order something and then do a little grocery shopping before hand. I usually end up still having to wait for extended amounts of time. Theres so much going on behind the counter that there is also usually a wait to have your order taken. One thing I may not be able to live without is their jack daniels wings. However, there is a Fridays in town that, after a little more of a drive, can fulfill that craving.
We moved to Wilmington about a year ago and have been looking for a new favorite pizza place. We found it with Brooklyn... we've ordered twice recently and each time the pizza was delicious. Perfect, big thin slices oozing with just the right amount of cheese. I'm from the south and have never had true NY pizza. Now we don't bother with the chains like Dominos or Pappa Johns anymore, Brooklyn is in a league of it's own! Really good stuff!
Brooklyn Pizza is the best pizza here in Wilmington. This is authentic New York Piza. There other items a great also. We love Brooklyn Pizza. You are right about Southerners not knowing good Italian food.
It is either too sweet or very Hot. Keep up the great work Brooklyn. The staff is great also.
Go to Wilmington each summer and wanted pizza this time. Saw all these reviews so my wife and i decided to go to brookly pizza. I will say this, we got to the parking lot before it opened so we waited. 10 minutes after it opened there were already 12 customers in the restaurant. The best pizza I have had in a long time. If you want good pizza go to this place. Just remember it is in the plaza with the Food Lion.
The name says it all, BROOKLYN PIZZA!! Ive noticed since living in NC that southern people have no idea whta italian food is!! They sent me to giorgios!! EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!! Brooklyn pizza is crispy the sauce is amazing. Anyone who doesnt like it isn't from up north!!
This is the best pizza in Wilmington. Bar none. Their pizza sauce is very tasty; not the same old you get from the chains. Their crust is excellent. No soggy, floppy stuff like you get from most pizzas. They keep their ovens hot enough to get it nice and crusty.
Whoever said this place was the same as others was completely clueless.
Best pizza in town! Period. Forget the chain stores, Domino's, Papa John's......You get the picture. I am from the south, and really dig the real NY style pizza! Thanks, Guy's! Keep up the excellent work! VERY fast delivery, sometimes 20-25 minutes! Piping hot too!