Had a similar experience to Don's. Went there with my family and the order was messed up and the owner was rude. Shame - use to go there three to four times a month. I now take my family to Immediato's Subs & Steaks which is less than two blocks away from Middletown Pizza.
I took my family to Middletown Pizza for dinner. The service was slow. Part of our order came out incorrectly and part of the order did not come out at all. We sent back the incorrect portion which came out incorrectly a second time. By the time we were ready to leave the rest of the order was ready. Our total bill game to $68.00. We were told we were going to get a discount for the errors. We expected the incorrect item as well as the missing item to be removed from the bill. Instead only $6.00 was removed. When we spoke to the owner he was extremely rude and refused to remove any additional charges. We have been to Middletown Pizza many times in the past and we will never go back again after the terrible customer service and the rudeness of the owner.