The pizza was soggy as hell and greasy,so was the stromboli. Plus when we got our food they gave us an italian sausage sub instead of the pizza we had ordered so had to wait another hr to get our correct order. papa johns is waaaaaaaaaaaaay better def. not what i expected from NY pizza place.
-Highly dissappointed Texan
i purchased a family pack last nite. the pizza was dry and the crust was hard. please put more sauce on your pizzas and go back to the wasy u use to cook your pizzas that was better. and also when i did pick up my order at the drive thru the boy walked by the window 3 times before he even came to window then a lady came to give me my order. THIS IS THE PUDGIES THAT MOVED FROM NORTH MAIN ST. TO COLLEGE AVE. WHY CHANGE PIZZA WHEN IT WAS GOOD ALREAADY..
This evening my wife and I decided to order pudgies subs. I got a cheesesteak with everything on it and she got a cold turkey with lettuce mayo and cheese. When the delivery driver got to the house (45 minutes later). He only had one sub with two fries!!! wtf! he was deaf (god bless his soul) and very polite. I had to call them back they decided to have him run back down here, they didn't put the fried onions and green peppers so i asked them to make that and put it on the side for me. The kind driver got back quickly, but the people at the store were rude and didn't even offer a refund or anything extra. i know they did it on purpose. I hope the restaurant goes out of buisness soon. I'm so glad they have a pudgies in the heights area now!! next time i'll go there or southside (maybe)
THE NEW WAVERLY PUDDGIES
I PURCHASED THE MAX PACK FOR NEW YEARS EVE TO MY SURPRISE I RECEIVED HAIR IN MY PIZZA THE HAIR WAS ACTUALLY BAKED INTO THE DOUGH!!NEEDLESS TO SAY MY FAMILY WILL NOT PURCHASE ANY THING THERE AGAIN AND I WILL SPREAD THE NEWS TO PEOPLE!!!