We have been regular customers at Uncle Joe's for 10 years and absolutely love the food and the very reasonable pricing and portions (unlike other area restaurants). Not only is it the best Italian food in the Hamptons in our opinion, but we have also been to Italy and honestly enjoy Uncle Joe's food more.
Since we have been going, four new Italian restaurants have opened between our home (in East Quogue) and Uncle Joe's (only three miles) but we willingly pass all of them, and you should too.
Located next to Boardy Barn in the Wild by Nature / Blockbuster shopping center, it's easy to pass by without noticing it because the landlord doesn't have a sign on Montauk Highway, but that would be a big mistake. While it looks like a basic pizzeria from the outside, there is also a separate dining room, with nice fabric table cloths and a full service bar, if you want a nicer dining experience. Uncle Joe's has been serving the best Italian food in the Hamptons for 25 years so eat where the locals eat - and get it at a good price too!
Uncle Joes Restaurant is the best restaurant in the whole wide world, I should know my family and I go often. Every new meal keeps your taste buds jumping wanting more. That isn't the best part, you get a great portion of food compared to most restaurants.The cheif at Uncle Joes is a phenominal cook that will mostly never refuse an order from the customer. My opinion of Uncle Joes over all would have to be it is the best Italian restsurant in New York.