Reservoir Tavern, Parsippany

Crispy crust, delicious sauce, excellent cheese.................wonderful Pizza. Try to go at an off hour.

It is obvious that people don't care about quality food. Place is too noisy, service poor and pizza is soggy. Star Tavern is far better with no noise and nicer atmosphere. Definitely not worth waiting a minute for much less an hour.

I finally tried the pizza at Reservoir Tavern in Parsippany.Although it was very good.I still think the Star Tavern in Orange.NJ is much better.I prefer the Star's thinner crust.

Fantastic, best I have ever had.

10 of 11 are right on! Pizza is the best but so is everything else. Pasta, bread, veal, etc. Steamed clams are delicious. I feel sorry for Lynn's husband or significant other. Waitress probably didn't jump up and down for her.

Absolutely worth the wait for a table. I'll wait at the bar for an hour, I don't care. I grew up with this pizza, it hasn't changed a bit in the past 20 years and I hope it never does.

I went hear after hearing people around town talk about it. Got a plain pie, disgusting, soggy and just plain gross. Then decided to try it a few months later after receiving a gift card and hoping the first time was just a fluke. But it wasn't, pizza again was soggy and gross, also ordered a few entrees and nothing great to say about them. Don't know what the buzz is about this place. Don't waste your money!!!!

The best pizza, decent service - the absolutely best pizza

Why is this place always crowded? Best pizza...crispy crust, great sauce, fresh cheese and toppings! Have even gone on busy Saturday nights and got good service. Just had to be understanding of how the waitress was very busy, and got extra attention in return.

Best pizza by far We have been going there for 5 generations and the pizza has not changed The meatball sandwiches are fantastic too