I Can't Believe It's Yogurt, Middlebury

Tried ICBY in Middlebury and enjoyed their smoothies very much. They use fresh fruit and yogurt with no ice or syrups. Owner is very knowledgeable on his products and takes time out to explain the healthy benefits of their frozen yogurt. Overall, I rate this establishment a 10 out of 10. Awesome. Thanks,

This store is a popular local find. The owner was friendly and knowledgeable, and went the extra mile.Loved the Yogurt, and the Gelato is the best I have had in a while. As a repeat customer, I recommend this place. David

I went to I Can't Believe It's Yogurt and was so pleased with the Owner. He was a true believer in his product. I must say I will be going back over and over again. I have been telling everyone about Tony's Store. It was so truly amazing. I loved the Frozen Yogurt. I also bought a cake with Yogurt and cake within. Everyone commented on how great it was. I am glad I found this store. JoAnn Adinolfi Holstein

This place is a rip-off and the owner is rude. I requested cherry dip and instead received a short education on hydrogenated oils and their health impact on me. I'm sorry, but the last thing anyone should be giving from behind the counter at an ice cream franchise is a HEALTH LESSON. Not to mention that 90% of the other toppings they offer contain the very same oils he was speaking against. Got two small soft serve cones and it cost near $8. Complete waste of time and money. Will not visit again.

Place is a rip-off ! Small coupon means "different small" according to owner. He is rude and obnoxious. Good luck in business buddy.

Yogurt is very good. Could get better ice cream at other places for less $$. Prices are sort of inconsistant....some things are reasonable, some are cheap, some are definitely overpriced. Owner can be rude and stingy and doesn't seem to like customers very much so try to avoid him.