Default
I'm a local, I eat there 2 to 3 times per week on avg for lunch. You can't beat 4.00 flat for 2 pizzas with a topping and soda. NY style pizza is pretty much the same everywhere, it's pretty hard to mess it up. If you see it, the sicillian is pretty good, and cheaper(???) (Paid 3.73 for two slices of sicillian the other day)
I much prefer the sausage and pepper sandwich on ciabatta though, thats my 'default'. I usually ask them to add mushrooms, they never charge extra for that.
The calzones are HUGE, they can easily feed 3 people. Def only order a small if you are eating alone. Other great thing they have is the house salad, pretty great value as well.
They also have decent beer on tap,(magic hat and rock art) but I certainly don't have a pint before going back to work!