Cafe Gelato is a very worthwhile dining destination.
The ambiance is delightful, and the food and service are top notch!
Best of all is the delight of carefully prepared and truly authentic Italian cuisine.
It's hard to believe that all this is on Main Street in Newark.

Great food, friendly staff, location with ambience...
I really enjoyed food, the downtown atmosphere and the outside seating

The atmosphere is nice, but a bit stuffy. Food was okay, but overpriced for what it was. The service was bad. I've been there twice in about 5 years and both experiences were bad. My soup came out after my entree without even an apology. Of course I still had to pay for it though I didn't want it anymore. Trying too hard to be an ...