People at the front desk were rude. No shuttle pick up at the Newark airport as promsied. Perhaps I would have had a better experience if I didn't speak English.

I love the place except for the parking its so crowded & I had to leave my keys with the attendant in the lot when we got ready to leave that morning had to walk quite a distance from point A to point B to get my keys. They had moved my car and I was upset about this, but overall I loved the hotel!!

Very clean hotel at a great price. Much more upscale than price indicates.

Easy access to NY City - take PATH from Penn Station (less than 10 minute walk) to World Trade Center. Simple, easy and affordable.

Airport shuttle. Penn Station shuttle.

Would stay again. Can't beat the rate.

The price is good compared to others in the same area, the room is very nice, clean, with a beautiful overlook. The service is good. actually I recommend it for anyone. I will stay in it again for mmy next visit to Nj

I truly wish I had read these reviews before booking at this hotel. I had the same problem someone below mentioned..plus more:
1)I booked a King bed, and was given a Queen with the front desk person saying "all" of the rooms were booked even though I reserved my King 14 days in advance online. Apparently they don't check their online ...

cleanliness i didnt need i always do my room, service could be better not everyone is nice, location excellent, value for bermudians very good one thing that i love about it that the rooms are big enought for at least four to five people. my dislikes i dont have any sorry its a great place

I found the staff at Robert Treat to be rude and unhelpful. I had to stay here for 6 weeks due to work, so I didn't want maid service every day. After a couple days of putting the "do not disturb" sign on my door, the housekeeping manager called me at 8 am on a Saturday morning to ask why I was "refusing service". It was ...

This hotel.... the "historic" Robert Treat... is not even in its original building. The current hotel is next door and was built in the 60's with completly diffrent architecture. Terrible experience... but a better price than staying in manhatten.
1) We were only given one room key for two people
2) We reserved a king sized bed but ...

first of all who is robert treat?,I stayed with my family and I felt my stay at this hotel was absolutely terrible. I only stayed in the hotel to sleep 4-5 hrs each day, yet in that time I could barely sleep.
there are bugs, cigarrette smoke, people walking in at 4 am and playing the elevators at 430 am. They then blast their tv sets at 5 am. This hotel should be investigated for foul play and incompetence.