Wonderful food, from the luscious oysters to the Bananas Foster. Too bad the waiter felt it necessary to evaluate us and insult us with little digs
culminating in a question as to where we live. Before we could answer, he offered his own guess- a least desirable town. It's a shame, but we won't be back.

Came to try out the food based mostly on hearing James Carpenter was the new Chef. We loved James at Della Femina.

Everything was average at best, especially considering what you pay (Welcome to Sag Harbor) Service was snotty, apparently smiling is not allowed.

James' food was strangely uninspired (except for the salad which was ...

The Hamptons meets the Adams Family.

I know personal attacks are frowned upon, but this adds to the whole experience of the American Hotel. The owner is a very creepy guy who has a Jack Russell Terrier who runs around the restaurant and defecates. When I pointed thus out to the owner, He told us to leave, or he would call the police. This was after we paid an $800 bill.

high prices but reliable great food in a romantic setting, with friendly waiters who always remember you (one dug me out of a snowbank two winters ago, after stopping and seeing my car had skidded off a deserted country road), and the menu always includes some dietetic additions. Also love the game in winter.

Been to this restaurant many times, most recently last weekend. Service was excellent. Setting is unique and inviting and on beautiful Sag Harbor main street. A place to be and a place to be seen. Not any more expensive than any other restaurant in the Hamptons. Menu is classic French with an emphasis on seafood. Make reservations! Especially if ...

I went for dinner with three men, all of us Asian and dressed in casual attire, but the manager warmly informed my party to "come back before noon tomorrow to apply for a job." I replied, "we'll come back tomorrow, can we have dinner now?" because we were only there to have a nice dinner. Aside from this incident, the food and service was fine.