<< To Scribner Hollow Lodge
Scribner Hollow Lodge - Reviews
Yahoo! User Reviews
AVERAGE OVERALL USER RATING
SERVICE
CLEANLINESS
LOCATION
VALUE
Been here before?
SORT BY:Most Recent  |  Positive  |  Negative  |  Most Helpful
  • More than we expected
    By Jim, 11/13/09
    Upon deciding to travel to the Catskills with some friends we chose Scribner Hollow as our lodging. We werent' sure what to expect but we were all pleasantly surprised. The staff was corteous, and attentive, the room had wonderful views and was clean and bright. It looked like it had been newly renovated. The restaurant was amazing! The ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • relaxing
    By Frank, 04/21/09
    Spent the weekend with over 50 friend and we had the place to ouor selves it was fantastic and relaxing. staff were friendly and nice.
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Well worth a revisit!
    By James, 03/25/09
    We were treated like friends, not strangers, during our stay. This is a classic mountain lodge. The view of the mountains was awesome. The suite was very cozy and well maintained by the staff. Also, there was always enough wood for the fireplace. The entire staff from the front desk, through the lounge and into the restaurant was courteous and ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • This is Our Kind of Place
    By Erin, 03/16/09
    Everything was perfect... owners, staff, food, suite, pool... it felt like home. The owners and staff were friendly and made us feel like we knew them a lifetime. The food was delicious - knowing good gourmet food, this came out on top. The room had an amazing view of Hunter Mountain.
    The cost was high but worth it considering it was all ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Fall Paradise...
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 11/25/08
    My husband and I celebrated our wedding at Scribner Hollow on Columbus Day weekend, 2008. It was a second wedding for both of us, and our desire was for an intimate, special celebration for family and a handful of friends, and it was. From the beginning planning stages until the day we left, our special event was nothing but perfect. Kate and Guy ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    5 of 5 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Personable Atmosphere & Attentive Staff
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/21/08
    I thought Scribner Hollow Lodge had charm and above all catered to its clientele. It is a family-owned lodge and I felt their personal attention to detail throughout the entirety of my stay. I have a disability and they catered to my every need above and beyond what most hotels would do. The dining room had a warm and friendly atmosphere, so much ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    5 of 5 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Splendor in the Mountains...a bit lengthy
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 04/26/08
    My fiancee and I were in search of a reception location for our Autumn 2008 wedding. Scribner Hollow was first on our list of possibilities. We booked an overnight stay in February, and were totally thrilled! We were warmly welcomed by the Lodge owner and shown to our room. Our room was spacious, and tastefully appointed in Adirondack style. It was ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    7 of 7 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • A Honeymoon to remember...
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 10/18/07
    We came to Scribner Hollow for our honeymoon, not knowing anything about the area but now we can not wait to return to Scribner Hollow for our first anniversary!

    The staff was so friendly, (they made us feel like family!!!) the food - amazing - fresh and a new special everyday, the room was clean, comfortable and romantic. If you are a wine ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    7 of 7 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • BIT PRICEY...BUT EXCELLENT STAY!
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 09/24/07
    just returned from our trip to scribner hollow in 9/20-9/22..I must say the trip was wonderful and the people at the lodge were very freindly. we stayed in the penthouse at the lodge which was outdated but was very cozy and clean for me and my wife. We were celebrating our 10th annaversary that weekend so i wanted it to be special for me and my ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    8 of 8 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Disgusting!
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 06/15/07
    I have to side with all the negative reviews. The positive reviews are a major misrepresentation. There is absolutely no quality in any of the services. The staff is rude. The rooms are dingy, outdated, dark and gloomy. After driving for several hours on a snowstorm last winter we were so disgusted and disappointed that we had to go elsewhere. ...
    Was this review helpful? Yes - No(Report Problem)
    1 of 12 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
Sign in to see your profile information, Trip Plans, and more...
Trip Planner
Save, organize and share your trip ideas with Trip Planner
<< To Scribner Hollow Lodge
Yahoo! Travel: Your best choice for cheap hotels and other great deals!
Portions copyright © 2009 ,