<< To Montauk Manor
Montauk Manor - Reviews
Yahoo! User Reviews
AVERAGE OVERALL USER RATING
SERVICE
CLEANLINESS
LOCATION
VALUE
Been here before?
SORT BY:Most Recent  |  Positive  |  Negative  |  Most Helpful
  • great
    By brian, 08/13/09
    nothing i loved the place favorite hotel indoor pool golf
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • GREAT VACATION GET AWAY
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/07/09
    I recently stayed at the Montauk Manor and what a great place for a family get away. They have daily activities for the kids, such a nice touch to give the adults a small break, much needed!

    The staff goes out of their way to make you feel at home. There wasn't anything that we asked for that was not addressed.

    I would lhighly ...
    2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
  • "Amazing Hill Top Castle"
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 03/28/09
    Let me start this by saying that my boyfriend and I were hesitant to stay here, after reading some of the other reviews. I called a few times, late in the evening, and spoke with Jim (he is wonderful!) about the place. He pointed out that accomodations do vary because they are condos owned by different individuals, and then gave us advice on which ...
    3 of 3 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Management Response to "was told t f---- off"
    By Janice, 08/20/08
    The mere fact that one would want to buy a place where one had experienced such "horrible services, a lack of restaurant, fraudulent credit charges and a stolen credit card" is suspect. However, Management wants to respond to the accusations by this Yahoo Contributor.

    The Montauk Manor prides itself on there service. The Manor has a ...
    5 of 6 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • was told t f---- off
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/03/08
    my wife and I have stayed at the manor several times when we were first married. Being young and in love, we did not notice the horrible service and lack of restaurant. we did notice the fraudulant credit charges on our credit card that one of the employees stole. we had to cancel that one. But several years later we considered purchasing one ...
    8 of 11 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Service was a Shame
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 07/28/08
    Great, grand hotel with horrible service. I've traveled the world and have never been treated like a criminal in a hotel like this. There was a "security deposit" for everything. I had to ask for an iron and was yelled at that they always disappeard, then my account was charged a security deposit fot it. Front desk staff acted ...
    9 of 10 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • We go back again & again.
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 05/19/08
    First of all, we have been going out to Montauk for quite a few years. We first stayed at the Manor 9 yrs. ago for our anniversary. It was a great stay then, and even better now. We were just there May 9th, and as usual, there was someone to open the majestic front doors for us with a friendly hello. The workers at the front desk could'nt be ...
    7 of 7 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Greatest Anniversary EVER!
    By ChrisC, 05/19/08
    I'm stunned by the person who complained last week here on Yahoo. My husband and I went to the Montauk Manor from Friday- Sunday to celebrate our 9th wedding anniversary and had the greatest weekend.

    My husband was instructed to check out Room 134. We could only get it for Friday night so we had a different room for the second night. ...
    6 of 7 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Condo Owner's Response
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 05/18/08
    The guests arrived on Tuesday afternoon on a Manor special “stay two nights, get the third night free”.

    This in response to their complaints;

    1) The scaffolding is on the East Side of the building, therefore, impossible to see from where the guests were staying.

    2) The first day, before the guests checked in, the first ...
    8 of 10 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
  • Caveat Emptor - A terrible experience
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 05/16/08
    Rude Service by entire staff and condo owner:
    Arriving on a beautiful day to celebrate our anniversary, we were greeted with construction crews all over the property beginning with three story scaffolding which made what was supposed to be a picturesque frontage unsightly. After checking in for our honeymoon suite, we were again greeted by ...
    8 of 14 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Value
Sign in to see your profile information, Trip Plans, and more...
Recent History
No recent history
Trip Planner
Save, organize and share your trip ideas with Trip Planner
<< To Montauk Manor
Yahoo! Travel: Your best choice for cheap airline tickets and other great deals!
Portions copyright © 2009 , ,