Also see: Wailea | Restaurants
<< To Nick's Fishmarket Maui
Nick's Fishmarket Maui - Reviews
Been here before?
Yahoo! User Reviews
AVERAGE OVERALL USER RATING
SORT BY:Most Recent  |  Positive  |  Negative  |  Most Helpful
  • Excellent
    By skywatch, 06/06/09
    This is one of best restaurants on the island. The Kea Lani is beautiful and sitting on the patio at Nick's at Sunset was truly charming.

    The service was exceptional. The staff put a lot of personality into their job unlike some nice restaurants were the staff is very "formal." I found this to be very refreshing and ...
    1 of 1 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Beyond Awful
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 11/20/07
    Once good, Nicks is worse every time we go. Now they are at rock bottom. It was well over an hour between the appetizers and the entree, three of seven meals had to be sent back as they were dry, cold and inedible after sitting under a heatlamp. We asked to speak to the manager, and the "manager" who came over was clearly not a person ...
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • avoid at all cost--spend your$ at duo
    By ciscobeach55, 08/16/07
    i recently stayed at the fairmont--the concierge desk recommended nick's since it is on the premises--what a mistake--i ordered a fresh oyster dish which i thought would be a good choice at a seafood restaurant--bad assumption--bad oysters on the plate--after i rejected the dish, the manager offered no apology and simply asked if i wanted to ...
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Don't miss this one!
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 02/21/07
    Great food, service and setting. We make it an annual stop! The menu is outstanding and the prepation is exquisite. Ask for a patio table when you make your reservation to watch the sunset.
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Disappointing
    By DICK L, 02/14/07
    Heard so much about this place. The actual experience was a letdown. Too hectic and too expensive. Service was attentive, but seemed to take forever.
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Where's my camera?
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 09/20/06
    Food was generally very good. Service OK. Took two steps out the door, realized our digital camera was left on the table. Immediately went back....everything cleared off already! Camera gone. ?????? Still waiting since January for an explanation.
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • just so so
    By naniling, 09/07/06
    It's just so so place to eat. The ambiance is pretty good but nothing special for the food and service. I rather spend my money going to Banyan Tree (Ritz) or Ferraro's (FS).
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Nicks - A Cut Above the Rest
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/31/06
    Nick's was the highlight of eating in HAwaii. Most of the food in Hawaii was fair at best. Nicks was outstanding. Instead of going to other restaurants we stuck iwth Nicks. Service was top notch, and the AHI Mignon was to die for. You'll pay, but well worth the experience. Anyone who thinks otherwise probably is a little over critical. Coming from a family with a 4 star restaurant, I think Nicks fits that label as well.
    2 of 2 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • Disappointed
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 08/24/06
    This past August, we dined at Nicks, as we do each summer, only to find the usually wonderfully attentive staff less than attentive. We experienced the following:
    1. It took approx. 10 minutes for anyone to acknowledge our presence at our table.
    2. It took another 30 minutes to get the 1st course (salads & soup).
    3. After finishing the ...
    1 of 1 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
    Service
    Cleanliness
    Location
    Value
  • The best dining experience of my life
    By A Yahoo! Contributor, 02/01/06
    The best experience of our lives. We went twice while on the island. We took our 8 year old, who had had her share of eating out. She giggled and was enchanted the entire evening. She would take a sip out of her water just to see a waiter literally run to fill it up. It was hysterical. I have never been so entertained by the staff. They all ...
    1 of 1 Yahoo! Users found this review helpful
    SHOW FULL REVIEW
    OVERALL
Sign in to see your profile information, Trip Plans, and more...
Recent History
No recent history
Trip Planner
Save, organize and share your trip ideas with Trip Planner
<< To Nick's Fishmarket Maui
Yahoo! Travel: Your best choice for cheap hotels and other great deals!
Portions copyright © 2009