My husband and I went here while on our honeymoon at Disney. First of all, the prices were rediculous for what you get. Especially considering our expirience was so horrible. Waiting for the show to be over was like waiting at the DMV. We waited, as painful as it was, for an extremely disgusting meal AND dessert. Not only that but they push how ...

First off the one thing that was such a suprise the show is a musical...and not a very good one. The actors are hard to understand and no plot atleast that i could tell. Felt like we were watch a musical at a high school not a $50 dinner. The food was ok nothing special and not very warm. Our seats were terrible even with reservations ahead of time ...

This show has to be written and performed with the 9 - 4 year old crowd in mind. I kept wondering if the cast were Disney rejects.

The food tasted freshly frozen, if you know what I mean. Would it hurt to invest in salt or pepper at least?

Service seemed to be given begrudingly, and then capped with an appeal of gratuity of $5 per head. ...

I assume you've been to a dinner-theater before. This one has a big pirate ship in the middle and beyond you shouting for your pirate, there are several levels of additional audience participation for an extra fee, so the fleecing of the guests was well thought out. The server didn't speak much English, the meal was small (but surprisingly ...

Rubber chicken, paste gravy, the smell of mold, horrible singing, obviously fake stunts, loud music... the list goes on. These are a few reasons why I do not like Pirates Dinner show. Not too mention that you are forced to pay your waiter an addition 15% tip for every member of your party, on top of the already pricey tickets. Even kids have to pay ...

Rubber chicken (as others have said before), very dark, smelled of musty water, loud, small portions. The singings was horrible and it was very expensive for the quality of food. I would never eat here. Arrgh ~ this show could improve a lot.

Very poor show and experience. Expensive, poor food, restricted view from rear seats and they tell each person to tip the waitress and how much, what a cheek. Poor "plot" acting and music. Poor organisation, after show disco, service and what a waste of money.

The food wasn't all that bad...shrimp was salty but ok. Need to offer a water/tea/coffee option for those who don't drink soda.
Our waitress (wench) was rather annoying. We had brought our baby who was only a few months and rather than letting us eat in peace (and the dark) she keep saying how precious he was...blah blah blah.
...

I went there last week and it was my first time going there. It is kind of expensive but the food and the people are good. It is a fun show to watch, where the actors incorporate the audience on the show so it is kind of cool.