I didn't have great experiences, it is just ok.
I think there a many more other restaurants on the island that deserve more praise, in the same price category.
Take it from an expat who lives here.

hi, i would love to be there now at dons, its a great place, great people and the best food on the island i think!! where can a country boy from the usa find butter milk in thailand???? at dons!!that was quite a big deal for me as i stay like 6 months at a time. also the most friendly people and don is a great guy too. had thanksgiving with him ...

It's overpriced. only go if you really just need a little something from home. otherwise, visit the night markets, experience a little more. i have yet to find a spot in thailand that can do foreign food as well as their own...even if it is by a farang. make one trip, and leave it at that.

This restraunt is one of the more American restraunts on the island, but I wouln't call it American. It's great for big groups and feel free to bring the kids. It's a very social restraunt and you are more than likely to walk away with a few more friends. For the most part the people who eat there are Thai women married to forigners ...