My daughter and I went a couple of months ago. Although, I haven't been there in years, I was quite surprised to read some of these negitive reviews.

I personally thought the pizza was as I always remember it, it was awesome!!! Lots of cheese, lots of pepperoni, black olives, it was the bomb! I loved it! We went around 2ish, so it ...

This pizza is not all that. The service does at times
suck. They need to hire more older/respondsible people. Spagetti Eddies is way better.

Overrated: After reading all the reviews here discussing how great the pizza is at Petrillos, we decided to check it out. We moved out here from NE Jersey outside NYC just last year and have been searching for a decent pie in the area. Wow, this place was really overrated. I found the pizza to be very pedestrain. I've had at least 2-3 ...

This place is soo overrated. The service absolutely sucked. The place wasn't even busy when I got there and it took over thirty minutes to get our small pizza and two plates of pasta to our table. Instead of actually doing their job, all of the staff was just standing around in the kitchen talking and laughing while I was getting impatient ...

I love the orignal in San Gabriel but this location leaves a lot to be desired. The girls who work the take out are just rude and could give a crap about service. The pizza was a bit too greasy. I did give this location another try, thought maybe they were having a bad day. Nope, same crappy attitude. My friends said the same. Save your money, go to spaghetti eddies, you will love it!!

I have been eating Petrillo's pizza since I was a kid. My parents took me to the original in San Gabriel at least once a month. I have never found another pizza place that can compare. I recently went to New York and couldn't wait to try their world famous pizza. I must say, I wasn't impressed. Although I haven't been to Chicago and ...

After reading all the reviews for years, I decided to try Petrillo's. I called my order in and was told it would be approx a 45 - 60 minute wait. It must have a great reputation for that kind of wait. When I arrived, the take-out area was crowded, but most people were still waiting.

My pizza (with all the toppings) was still a few ...

I may not be a leading authority on Pizza, but I have eaten some of the best pizza in the country including Frank's pizza in Silvis, IL and quite a few places in Chicago. This place is right up there. As far as service, I have never had an issue at all. AWESOME TASTE, AND AWESOME SERVICE...and while I don't know any of them personally, ...

Wow they have the best pizza in town if you are looking for some absolutely awesome tasting pizza with the googey thick cheese and wonderful aroma from the garlic I always ask for garlic on mine. I am always trying to look out what I eat and I do pretty good except when it comes to Petrillo's I always tend to over do it's just too good to ...