We dined at he Painted Pony on New Years Eve. We had never been there before but the others in our group had. I had high hopes since the area looked like "Trolley Square" does up here. I was VERY DISAPPOINTED!
I ordered the Rib eye Steak with red wine sauce. The price for which was $30. Something I was surprised about considering ...

We dined at The Painted Pony for New years, the presentation was good, the wine" GREAT" .However, the food although well presented was not very good, the meat was cold and the chicken was dry, the service was not up to par for a four star restaurant. We were there early enough that they were not very busy. After spending almost $300.00, They should step it up.

My first two dinners there were incredible- interesting and delicious. But my third dinner there was heavily salted- but it was a very busy night.